| August 30th, 2025 | 1-3 | Louisville | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| October 4th, 2025 | 2-0 | Louisville | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| April 6th, 2024 | 5-3 | Louisville | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| October 5th, 2024 | 2-2 | Tie | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| May 27, 2023 | 0-1 | Louisville | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| July 29, 2023 | 2-0 | Louisville | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| August 31, 2022 | 2-1 | Indianapolis | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| March 26, 2022 | 1-1 | Draw | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| October 16, 2021 | 1-0 | Indianapolis | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| September 18, 2021 | 0-2 | Louisville | Carroll Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| June 26, 2021 | 3-3 | Draw | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| May 29, 2021 | 1-2 | Indianapolis | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| August 8, 2020 | 1-1 | Draw | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season* | 
| August 26, 2020 | 1-0 | Louisville | Lynn Family Stadium | USL-C Regular Season* | 
| September 5, 2020 | 1-3 | Louisville | Lucas Oil Stadium | USL-C Regular Season* | 
| September 16, 2020 | 2-0 | Louisville | Lucas Oil Stadium | USL-C Regular Season* | 
| June 29, 2019 | 1-1 | Draw | Lucas Oil Stadium | USL-C Regular Season | 
| August 30, 2019 | 1-1 | Draw | Slugger Field | USL-C Regular Season | 
| November 9, 2019 | 1-3 | Louisville | Carroll Stadium, IUPUI | USL Eastern Conference Final | 
| October 20, 2018 | 4-1 | Louisville | Slugger Field | USL Playoffs | 
| October 13, 2018 | 0 - 1 (PK) | Louisville | Slugger Field | USL | 
| August 5, 2018 | 2 - 2 | -DRAW- | Slugger Field | USL | 
| May 5, 2018 | 1 (PK) - 0 | Indianapolis | Lucas Oil Stadium | USL | 
| March 18, 2017 | 1 - 1 | -DRAW- | Evansville, IN | Friendly | 
| June 1, 2016 | 2 - 1 | Indianapolis | Carroll Stadium, IUPUI | US Open Cup | 
| March 19, 2016 | 1 - 0 | Louisville | Slugger Field * | Friendly | 
| May 27, 2015 | 0 - 2 | Louisville | Carroll Stadium, IUPUI | US Open Cup | 
| October 27, 1945 | 1 - 1 | Louisville | Grünwalder Stadion | One-off WWII Victory Match | 
| January 2, 1942 | 1 - 1 | Louisville | Grünwalder Stadion | Part of celebrations following the signing of the UN charter the day before. | 
| July 18, 1937 | N/A | N/A | Madison, Indiana | Rock Throw Cookout | 
| July 4, 1936 | 0 - 4 | Indianapolis | Central State Hospital Grounds | The teams put on an exhibition match for researchers and patients for Independence Day | 
| November 9th, 1932 | 1 - 2 | Indianapolis | Indiana State Fairgrounds | The teams played a celebration game for the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt | 
| August 4 & August 20 1926 | 1 - 1 | Draw | Flood zone | N/A | 
| May 27, 1925 | 4 - 1 | Indianapolis | Indiana Fairgrounds | Coca-Cola Cocaine Classic | 
| October 4, 1921 | 19 - 7 | Indianapolis | Newark, NJ | Pre-World Series exhibition match | 
| May 27, 1918 | 3 - 1 | Louisville | Kentucky State Fairgrounds | Jib-Jab Footballery Challenge | 
| May 27, 1878 | 9 - 8 | Louisville | Churchill Downs Infield | Kentucky Derby Sporting Goodtimes Championship | 
| September 2, 1868 - 'The Bloody Affair' | 0 - 0 | Draw | Indianapolis Motor Speedway Infield | N/A | 
| April 18, 1865 | 4 - 4 | Draw | Louisville's Taylor Barracks drill field | A battle match to take the country's attention off the assassination of Abraham Lincoln, reigniting the rivalry after disruption by the Civil War | 
| 1280 BC - 1900 AD | ??? | Lost to history | The old country, the new world | LIPAFC reportedly the model for the Olympics. Only the Watchers and Stan Lee's ghost know for sure. |